Sunday, January 24, 2010

shame on us


there isn't anything we can do about it now, but the take home message from today's service was a little sad.

"we are sorry."

not once, but twice did ruben clemente, the leader of humc's hispanic "ministry", feel as though he had to apologize on behalf of his congregation for perceived transgressions made towards the facilities we have been allowing them to use for several years.

"we are sorry our children scratched/colored on your walls."

"we are sorry that we spilled sodas on the carpets."

"again, we are sorry."

------------------------------------------

"please stop sending me hate letters."

"we are leaving now."

"you don't have to worry about us anymore."

"good riddance."

ok, ok. the last four were made up by me and kiker, but it felt like they would have been appropriate considering the tone of ruben's choice of words.

the message that we have been sent concerning ruben's group and their departure is that they no longer felt safe in our community. and to be fair, there is a very real cultural barrier that separates hispanics and blacks in general, not just in huffman. part of that sentiment may be true. but the message that ruben delivered this morning was different.

i am paraphrasing...

"we started in your parlor. we outgrew your parlor (read: they broke something and were asked to move.). we moved into your chapel. we outgrew your chapel (read: they probably broke something in there too.). we moved downstairs into your basement. we used your fellowship hall. we used nursery and sunday school class rooms. we have baptized over forty adults in the name of christ since we have been using your building. we feel like we are doing god's work." but, we are really sorry about that one time one of our girls stuck her arm through one of your doors. we suck. and are careless. forgive us. please. don't be mad at us anymore. she is fine now, by the way. thanks for asking. lucy, show them your scar.

again, that last part is mine.

don't get me wrong. there were all sorts, and i mean ALL SORTS of communication stumbling blocks and issues with this relationship from the get-go. it took a couple years for the majority of our congregation to realize that there was, even, a group of hispanics meeting in our building. when people complained and things boiled to a head, we, collectively, chose to "support" and own the group as our hispanic "ministry", implying that we were doing them a favor by letting them use our place, but keeping them, still, at an arm's length. by that point, the damage had already been done. ruben didn't feel welcome. we weren't going out of way to make them feel welcome. he started looking around. dcd started helping them look. harris came on board and they already had one foot out of the door.

it's probably for the best. for, as vibrant a ministry as ruben may have been leading, the ministry was connected by several tentacles to the era at our church that we are now trying to lead ourselves out of. the era of trusting and then blaming the pastor for everything that goes right or wrong. the era of nobody having any idea of what anybody else is doing. the era of committees in name only. the d.i.a. era, full or something or another, but really signifying nothing. the era of longtime members looking for reasons to leave and then finding them in scapegoat drama, sunday school classes or pastors. the era that will mark, if we don't do something about it, the beginning of the end.

ruben's ministry was the last true tie to that unfortunate era. as a matter of fact, their group serves as a wonderful metaphor and cautionary tale all at the same time. the hispanic group thrived. at the same time, other good and godly things happened at our church. ministry has not ceased to exist. but each man and woman and ministry have been operating on their own island, set adrift from any central or mainland message that will always welcome our missionaries home with open arms and a singular purpose.

lessons can be learned from the aforementioned era, and we will continue to examine them in the future, hopefully in contrast to something new and improved. hopefully, in this peace and quiet that we now find ourselves in, we may discern subtle and impactful ways to do god's work. hopefully, we can figure out what we want to be as a church in the middle of a huffman community with so many needs to be filled.

and hopefully, the next time a non-member addresses a portion of our congregation to express his or her thanks for the use of our facilities, he or she won't be made to feel like stains in the youth room define their experience.

7 comments:

Kathy said...

It's a shame that whoever (the pastor?) was communicating with Ruben did such a poor job. After all, the problem wasn't stains on the carpet. Yes, it's a shame someone led Ruben to believe that we were upset about stains on the carpet and therefore mad at his congregation. It's a shame that whoever was communicating with Ruben wasn't willing to own the fact that the problem started with us and that that's where the solution should have started. It's a shame we had a representative who was so ignorant of the true problem that he managed to place the responsibility on Ruben's shoulders and make us look petty in the process.

I won't accept the blame for Ruben feeling put upon. That was never the message we intended to send, in my opinion.

Reagan said...

As a visitor, I won't lie and say that it didn't make me feel bad for the guy and that it didn't raise a question or two in my mind. First, I would've liked to have seen the minister, in front of the congregation, tell him something to help him feel that would make the guy feel better. The "apology" he gave was obviously more than just a "hey, if something happened, I'm sorry but thank you so much" and moving on...

I guess second, at the end of the day, that building is God's and the work "we" do or "you" did to minister to them is His as well. I understand that it sucks to have something happen because I've seen similar situations but the money to repair, the time to repair, the building being repaired, etc... Is it not all God's? Are we only supposed to minister when it's easy with no complications? I don't believe so. I think the numbers he presented is awesome but I as someone that will obviously consider joining, I can't say I wonder about it. Great stuff Kev.

kevin said...

i agree with you both, kathy and reagan.

you aren't to blame. neither am i. which puts the shame squarely on the collective "us". a classic sin of omission.

the collective we, the congregation, knew things weren't going well. in ways, the collective contributed to it not going well. and yet, we trusted our "leaders" at the time would find a common ground for us to move forward together on. unfortunately, that didn't happen, and, now, we've learned our lesson the hard way.

here's hoping that having a fresh or refreshed (as i hope i now have) perspective will help melt some of our cynical hearts and move us into a more healthy future.

Sandra G. said...

From an ignorant but interested outsider, a couple of observations:
It seems to me that two communities of Christ, with vast cultural differences, have struggled to coexist in one facility for several years. The effort was not carried out perfectly. It never is. But those of you who chose to stay, both HUMC members and Hispanics, because you loved your God, your church and each other too much to give up, are to be commended. The Hispanic community is moving on. They're not self-destructing. They've just found somewhere else to meet. The real triumph here are those 40 adult who were baptized during their sojourn at HUMC. So before you feel too dirty or sad, go to the website www.northalabamaumc.org and look at the dashboard that gives statistics for all the UMC congregations in N. Alabama. Compare the number of adult baptisms for the same period of time with yours. Aren't we in business to bring souls to Christ? In my humble opinion the past few years at HUMC will be seen as a glowing period in the church's some 139-year history. I can't wait to see what surprises God has in store for you next. Blessings!

Mark Durham said...

We will pay for this.

Hebrews 3:7-9 (New International Version)

7 So, as the Holy Spirit says:
"Today, if you hear his voice,
8 do not harden your hearts
as you did in the rebellion,
during the time of testing in the desert,
9 where your fathers tested and tried me
and for forty years saw what I did.

We invited a group that was then made to feel so unwelcome they left, and feel like we were wronged when they apologized for damage done to the church?

I don't see good things for our church until we repent for this. Christ did not assign us guardians of salvation, we are to administer his kingdom until he returns. To me, that means bringing people in and celebrating differences. I feel we failed miserably.

I do take responsibility for this. I was behind the formation of the group when Rick introduced it. I was on SPRC when we drew up what we though would be top priority for Chris to work on when he arrived (integration of this ministry and our congregation was on the top of the list). I tried to pull together the two opposing sides when this threatened to splinter the church. I attempted to point out the difference between requesting others to abide by our rules and unwarranted racism to our congregation.

I failed you God and I failed my church, and I am sorry. I will try to strengthen my faith and temper my fire should you chose to test your servant again.

Jacobs said...

You know the real crime here? That the downstairs room has no use anymore...or does it?

donnag said...

You wrote: ...we, collectively, chose to "support" and own the group as our hispanic "ministry", implying that we were doing them a favor by letting them use our place...
I just read something last night about people who grow up knowing only one culture and language who are basically ignorant of the diversity of cultures around them. They project their own perceptions to other cultures and assume that people should be like them and judge people's actions and attitudes based on their own. This point was in the context of carrying out God's mission of reconciling a broken world to God. The point was that this "I'm doing you a favor by ministering to you" attitude will not reconcile the world. Learning other cultures, understanding diverse societies and personally interacting with people will nuture spiritual fellowship. Your comment kind of connected the book I was reading with an actual situation.
Having said that, I agree that there was a severe lack of communication and understanding of the relationship from the very beginning that just set the tone for continued misunderstandings.